I believe people are overlooking the fact that CASPER is worth 33%. The same way a 3.95+, 130+ CARS applicant would need a "good" CASPER to presumably be close to top 100, a 3.95+, 128 CARS, that killed CASPER would probably put him in that same range. We don't know the distributions for each category. I think there would definitely be high GPA, MCATS in the top 100, but seeing high stats without a button does not disprove the button theory to me. They could be just outside the top 100. Regardless , we just have to wait till Tuesday before we can comment on the button.