I think you guys should all go for Scotia.
Scotia's visa points are just slightly lower than RBCs in dollar amount (Scotia 3125 pts per $25 vs. RBCs 3000 pts per $25) but Scotia does not charge an annual $120 premium.
RBC's special "100,000 pts for any round trip around the world up to $2000" may seem good at first but when I looked into it, they exclude surcharges and taxes, which add up to $400-500. I have close to 100,000 RBC pts after 4 years. I looked up a trip that I would've paid $1200 for on Expedia and it would cost me 100,000 RBC points + $450. Had I redeemed those 100,000 points straight up I would've gotten $825.
Scotia's debit card even gives you rewards too (in Scene pts), while RBCs gives nothing.
Scotia has a higher max at $275,000, RBCs is $225,000, maybe $250,000.
Seems to me like Scotia is a clear winner unless you guys can see a mistake.