James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 1 minute ago, MDLD said: ugh i hate all this. I have a button and I really don't want a regional campus. Would you rather be randomized to reject tho? Few really want regional campuses first choice (those that do always get them obviously) but all will come to accept and even love it Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MDLD Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 Just now, Anon_9 said: Was just going to suggest that but I feel like we are thinking about this way too deeply guys. This button is most likely meaningless i'm hoping so going to have nightmares about this button for the next two days Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 I feel like this thread rn is group therapy for Mac applicants for both the button and the lottery Anon_9, conditional knockout, pretomd and 1 other 2 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anon_9 Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 1 minute ago, MDLD said: i'm hoping so going to have nightmares about this button for the next two days Same man same Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lizaloo223 Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 2 minutes ago, Anon_9 said: Same man same Yea I feel like trying to figure out some logic and reasoning in this time of uncertainty (covid, lottery everything lol) rally helps. Even if the button is likely meaningless, trying to "solve it" is kinda therapeutic lmao Anon_9 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MDLD Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 4 minutes ago, William Osler said: Would you rather be randomized to reject tho? Few really want regional campuses first choice (those that do always get them obviously) but all will come to accept and even love it yeah by no means if I don't get anywhere i would take it in a heart beat. Just have family and relationships in hamilton. So it was the perfect match in many ways. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 1 minute ago, lizaloo223 said: Yea I feel like trying to figure out some logic and reasoning in this time of uncertainty (covid, lottery everything lol) rally helps. Even if the button is likely meaningless, trying to "solve it" is kinda therapeutic lmao Load clown memes if button = reject or meaningless Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MedicineLCS Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 Since when are applicants given their "first choice" campus based on ranking? We were all sent an email explicitly saying that campus selection is by lottery (sorry for triggering anyone) "if one campus is undersubscribed". Quote In the event that one or more campuses are under-subscribed, a lottery will be run to determine which applicants will receive their second or possibly even their third choice of campus. I suppose they could weigh their lottery odds by ranking, but to me, it really does sound like campus selection comes down to chance/your preference helps it. Which makes sense in evenly distributing applicants. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anon_9 Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 My friend who said that it's definitely a meaningless glitch said that the error probably "maxed out" before it could affect the rest of the mac applicants (whatever that means). It could just be that for some reason, the code that is supposed to "reveal" the button got accidentally switched on just (maybe a typo or smtg) and only some mac applicants are seeing it because it maxed out before it could appear for the rest of the applicants. We can't say for certain that only average applicants are seeing the button (hence the lottery peeps) and high applicant non-buttoners are in the top 100 because so many non-buttoners have stats on all areas of the spectrum and some buttoners have very high stats. DonutLover 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JayKay Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 The spotted post comments are some of the dumbest I have ever seen. as for the choosing the top 206 applicants based on pre-interview formula, I think the reason I wouldn’t want them to do it is because it would result in a class with a skewed GPA and CARS. I think the purpose of randomly selecting is to match the stats of the current MD class. From a strict statistical point of view I understand. From an applicant perspective I really would have them used 70% Casper or just not have told us it was a lottery. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MDLD Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 1 minute ago, Anon_9 said: My friend who said that it's definitely a meaningless glitch said that the error probably "maxed out" before it could affect the rest of the mac applicants (whatever that means). It could just be that for some reason, the code that is supposed to "reveal" the button got accidentally switched on just (maybe a typo or smtg) and only some mac applicants are seeing it because it maxed out before it could appear for the rest of the applicants. We can't say for certain that only average applicants are seeing the button (hence the lottery peeps), because so many non-buttoners have stats on all areas of the spectrum. im just going to belive this becuase it makes me ldea stressed out. Thank you friend for me. Do you think that it could do by alphabetical order of who got effected first? My last name is at the begining of the alphabet and my first is in the middle. Anon_9 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 Lets just all believe button = meaningless and move on with our lives till then Anon_9 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lizaloo223 Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 3 minutes ago, Anon_9 said: My friend who said that it's definitely a meaningless glitch said that the error probably "maxed out" before it could affect the rest of the mac applicants (whatever that means). It could just be that for some reason, the code that is supposed to "reveal" the button got accidentally switched on just (maybe a typo or smtg) and only some mac applicants are seeing it because it maxed out before it could appear for the rest of the applicants. We can't say for certain that only average applicants are seeing the button (hence the lottery peeps) and high applicant non-buttoners are in the top 100 because so many non-buttoners have stats on all areas of the spectrum and some buttoners have very high stats. 1 minute ago, MDLD said: im just going to belive this becuase it makes me ldea stressed out. Thank you friend for me. Do you think that it could do by alphabetical order of who got effected first? My last name is at the begining of the alphabet and my first is in the middle. But all the button people with high stats didn't get interviews at Ottawa or other Casper schools.... but then again by all I mean like 3 people so hardly conclusive data XD Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 4 minutes ago, JayKay said: or just not have told us it was a lottery. I respect Mac for sticking to their word and being transparent pre D-Day. HOWEVER, I do not respect them for just throwing their hands in the air and not arranging a virtual interview when every other school in the country managed to do so and relying on statistics Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anon_9 Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 1 minute ago, MDLD said: im just going to belive this becuase it makes me ldea stressed out. Thank you friend for me. Do you think that it could do by alphabetical order of who got effected first? My last name is at the begining of the alphabet and my first is in the middle. Who knows haha, my last name is mid-early in the alphabet, first name is middle. 2 minutes ago, William Osler said: Lets just all believe button = meaningless and move on with our lives till then Yeah that's what I am planning on doing. I keep coming back to this thread in case one of you all cracked the code or something crazy is revealed LOL... I think we all just need to take a LONG nap and wake up Monday evening. See you all then. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 Just now, Anon_9 said: Yeah that's what I am planning on doing. I keep coming back to this thread in case one of you all cracked the code or something crazy is revealed LOL... I think we all just need to take a LONG nap and wake up Monday evening. See you all then. This thread was honestly such a roller coaster ride. By the way, everyone should stop responding on page 69 for the memes MDrapper 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 Is anyone's first choice school Mac anymore? (If so, why?) Has the lottery and cancellation of MMI changed your perspective on them? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hehe123 Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 1 minute ago, William Osler said: Is anyone's first choice school Mac anymore? (If so, why?) Has the lottery and cancellation of MMI changed your perspective on them? Possible reasons: - proximity to family (existing housing in hamilton, etc...) - familiarity (undergrad at mac, knows researchers/faculty, community, etc...) - 3 year - couples avoiding long distance relationships - only offer - pbl - for the memes noku95 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MDLD Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 and now there is a meme... James Nystead 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
fingerscrossed2020 Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 To add another theory, based on the assumption that button=offer: I agree that those with the button are those who were randomized to offer, and the high stats/top 100 people haven't been released yet. One of the issues with the lottery is that it could introduce transparency issues—there's room for people to be preferentially chosen (based on connections, etc.) and it be justified as 'lottery.' Super unlikely, but some could make the argument. Mac could've asked a third party, i.e. OMSAS in this case, to randomize applicants to an offer and then send that data back to them. That way, they aren't involved with the lottery offer component, at least. In the process of OMSAS selecting those who would receive an offer based on the lottery, they might've triggered the appearance of The Button. That could explain the range of stats in the button group, and why high stats people with interviews to CASPer schools don't have them—because Mac has the list of top 100 and OMSAS wasn't involved in generating that list. I also feel like OMSAS isn't made to determine 'top 100' since they'd have to compile and standardize so many scores. I strongly agree that coming up with theories is therapeutic haha thank goodness for this thread Edit: I know a couple high-stats people without buttons who didn't rank Hamilton as their top choice, so that's another reason I don't think button=regional campus M9V and lakeshore 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ejvrei Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 (I'm so sorry to continue this thread when it may be slowing down... I just read through these) I just want to add that I am one of the buttons with 130 CARS and 3.9+ GPA (rejected from Ottawa though so who knows about CASPer but I thought it was relatively fine?) and my first choice campus was a regional campus... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
:(( Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 1 hour ago, wowfactor said: I divided you guys into 3 groups. 1. People with Button GPA 3.6 / 130 - BUTTON GPA 3.96 / 125 - BUTTON GPA 3.79 / 128 - BUTTON GPA 3.75 / 129 - BUTTON GPA 3.85 / 128 - BUTTON GPA 3.91 / 127 - BUTTON GPA 3.92 / 129 - BUTTON GPA 3.90 / 128 - BUTTON GPA 3.91 / 129 - BUTTON GPA 3.96 / 129 - BUTTON GPA 3.95 / 130 (did not apply to Casper-heavy school) - BUTTON GPA 3.85 / 131 - BUTTON GPA 3.96 / 130 (R from UOttawa) - BUTTON GPA 3.98 / 130 (R from UOttawa) - BUTTON 2. People without Button with higher stats (GPA 3.95 + OR /AND CARS 129+) GPA 3.98 / 132 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.97 / 130 - NO BUTTON GPA 4.0 / 131 - NO BUTTON Another GPA 4.0 / 131 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.95 / 131 - NO BUTTON GPA 4.0 / 129 - NO BUTTON Another GPA 4.0 / 129 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.98 / 130 - NO BUTTON Another GPA 3.98 / 130 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.98 / 129 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.97 / 129 - NO BUTTON GPA 4.0 / 130 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.96 / 130 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.97 / 132 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.95 / 130 - NO BUTTON 3. People without Button with similar stats with people with Button GPA 3.87 / 125 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.96 / 128 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.84 / 132 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.89 / 129 - NO BUTTON GPA 3.90 / 129 - NO BUTTON The button should mean something, and I am really excited to see which one (group 1 or 3 ) will be accepted at Mac with group 2. Every one of us must be curious about it, so let's add button/no button on the acceptance/ rejection thread. I have the button as well, 3.87/128 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James Nystead Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 5 minutes ago, fingerscrossed2020 said: To add another theory, based on the assumption that button=offer: I agree that those with the button are those who were randomized to offer, and the high stats/top 100 people haven't been released yet. One of the issues with the lottery is that it could introduce transparency issues—there's room for people to be preferentially chosen (based on connections, etc.) and it be justified as 'lottery.' Super unlikely, but some could make the argument. Mac could've asked a third party, i.e. OMSAS in this case, to randomize applicants to an offer and then send that data back to them. That way, they aren't involved with the lottery offer component, at least. In the process of OMSAS selecting those who would receive an offer based on the lottery, they might've triggered the appearance of The Button. That could explain the range of stats in the button group, and why high stats people with interviews to CASPer schools don't have them—because Mac has the list of top 100 and OMSAS wasn't involved in generating that list. I also feel like OMSAS isn't made to determine 'top 100' since they'd have to compile and standardize so many scores. I strongly agree that coming up with theories is therapeutic haha thank goodness for this thread Edit: I know a couple people who would fit into the 'high stats' category who didn't rank Hamilton as first, so that's another reason I don't think button=regional campus This is a great explanation for why mid-range stats applicants have the button instead of regional campus explanation Still leaning that its meaningless, but interesting theory tho Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MDLD Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 9 minutes ago, fingerscrossed2020 said: To add another theory, based on the assumption that button=offer: I agree that those with the button are those who were randomized to offer, and the high stats/top 100 people haven't been released yet. One of the issues with the lottery is that it could introduce transparency issues—there's room for people to be preferentially chosen (based on connections, etc.) and it be justified as 'lottery.' Super unlikely, but some could make the argument. Mac could've asked a third party, i.e. OMSAS in this case, to randomize applicants to an offer and then send that data back to them. That way, they aren't involved with the lottery offer component, at least. In the process of OMSAS selecting those who would receive an offer based on the lottery, they might've triggered the appearance of The Button. That could explain the range of stats in the button group, and why high stats people with interviews to CASPer schools don't have them—because Mac has the list of top 100 and OMSAS wasn't involved in generating that list. I also feel like OMSAS isn't made to determine 'top 100' since they'd have to compile and standardize so many scores. I strongly agree that coming up with theories is therapeutic haha thank goodness for this thread Edit: I know a couple high-stats people without buttons who didn't rank Hamilton as their top choice, so that's another reason I don't think button=regional campus how many is a couple... just wondering Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MedicineLCS Posted May 10, 2020 Report Share Posted May 10, 2020 16 minutes ago, fingerscrossed2020 said: To add another theory, based on the assumption that button=offer: I agree that those with the button are those who were randomized to offer, and the high stats/top 100 people haven't been released yet. I'll preface my point by repeating that speculation is pointless (but it does pass the time!). That being said. The % of buttons in the thread has remained consistently between 50-60% for Mac interviewees (32 as of my last count). If there are still a 100 applicants who get offers this percentage skyrockets. Even if you believe in response bias/a more competitive pool (which I do) that would be extremely high for first round offers. The whole "high CARS/GPA=top 100" is missing that CASPer makes up a solid 1/3rd of the preinterview score. It's perfectly possible that the majority consists of people with high-mid stats (130+, 3.8+) who really nailed CASPer. At the same time, it's possible the person with the 4.0/132 bombed CASPer (comparatively) and was carried to an interview on their stats largely. Before making theories it's worth checking the assumptions, which I don't think are valid. I did something similar to the stats grouping previously posted, and I can tell you, when you sort by GPA or CARS score it's not "no button" from the top to some random place in the middle where they shop up. Buttons pop up, randomly seemingly, up and down the range of possible scores reported. Someone with a 132 has a button. Someone with a 4.0 has the button. Both are not slouches in the other number. Add in self-reported scores bias and it's quite apparent that it's all over the range. Add in a MASSIVE CASPer black box and I think making theories is pointless. The button is tied to acceptances in the past and in videos, we'll see if that's true on May 12th. MD_Dream97, MDrapper and reginageorge 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.